Rules for Reviewing and Publishing Scientific Articles

All the articles submitted to the journal are registered and within 5 days are subject to primary consideration for compliance with the journal’s scope, the quality and layout standards, as completeness.

Articles previously not published, in the excess of 15 % of the content, in other printed and/or electronic editions, except the publication of the preprint (manuscript) of the article, are accepted for publication.

Checking papers to identify unlawful borrowings is carried out with the help of “Antiplagiat” (“anti-plagiarism”) software. The editors of the journal do not publish articles with less than 80 % originality of the text (however, borrowing from a single source cannot exceed 7 %). The exception is borrowings from the author’s publications, which describe the scientific results obtained and published earlier in other scientific editions; in such case, reference to previously published materials of the author is mandatory).

The editors shall inform the authors on the results of primary examination of the materials.

The article may be declined from publication, with a relevant justification, in the following cases:

- it does not comply with the journal’s scope and the established requirements to layout and completeness of supporting materials;

- the manuscript text originality is below 80 % (as proved by “Antiplagiat” (“anti-plagiarism”) software), contains inappropriate borrowings;

- over 15 % of the content was earlier published in other printed or online sources;

- the manuscript meets formal requirements, but clearly fails to comply with content criteria for scientific publications and does not keep up the high level of the journal;

- the research article content is limited in use.

The editors carry no responsibility to store the articles that had been rejected for publication.

The manuscript, accompanied by a relevant justification, is to be returned to the author for amendments if it does not comply with the formal requirements for the layout and completeness, but, in the editors’ point of view, falls well into the content criteria. The editors may ask for missing materials or recommend amending the manuscript to meet the layout requirements.

The article confirming to the journal’s scope and meeting the requirements to the layout, quality and completeness of materials will be included into the editing cycle and is then forwarded for the peer review. Peer review is fulfilled in accordance with the Regulations on Peer Review of Manuscripts of Articles Submitted for Publication in “Ars Administrandi” (“The Art of Governance”) Scientific Journal.

Articles accepted for consideration will be made anonymous, i.e., the editorial board secretary will remove the author’s indication from the manuscript text and from the “Information about the authors” section. The manuscript is then forwarded to the chief editor (depute chief editor), who is to take a decision on peer review, within 7 days. Choosing reviewers is the competence of the chief editor (depute chief editor).

Within 3 days after the decision on peer review has been taken, the editorial board secretary forwards the anonymized manuscript to the appointed reviewer. The peer reviews should be qualified specialists in the topic areas of the materials under review and have publications during the three previous years on the topic of the article under review.

Each manuscript will be reviewed at least by two specialists. The reviewers should keep to the Regulations on Publication Ethics Standards of Perm State University and the Regulations on Ethics and Disputes Settlement in Publishing Articles in “Ars Administrandi” (“The Art of Governance”) Scientific Journal. Additional peer review may be appointed in case the article is of an inter-disciplinary or discussion character or should any disputes on its quality arise with the reviews.

Peer review deadlines will be set for each case specifically taking into consideration creating conditions for most speedy review; however, these should not exceed 30 days since the article and the request to the reviewer have been sent. The deadlines may be extended in case additional review is needed and/or temporary absence of the reviewer with necessary qualification. Total review period, with the account of possible amendments into the article by the author and its further repeated review, should not exceed three months. The author may not amend the manuscript for more than two times.

Should the reviewers take the decision as stated in Para 4.7.5 of the Regulations on Peer Review of Manuscripts of Articles Submitted for Publication in “Ars Administrandi” (“The Art of Governance”) Scientific Journal, the chief editor (depute chief editor) will approve it for publishing in one of the issues of the journal. The chief editor (depute chief editor) makes the final decision on publishing or denying publication.

Before it is published, the article is checked by the language editor, proof-reading and technical refinement, which can be affected both with and without involvement of the author. Editing and correcting involving the author will be done through data and information exchange between the author and the editors by e-mail.

The editors retain the right to abridge or make amendments into the articles approved for publishing (internal review/scientific review), including in printed copy preparation.

Copy editing, corrections and technical refinement are affected under the licensing agreement and the Regulations on Ethics and Disputes Settlement in Publishing Articles in “Ars Administrandi” (“The Art of Governance”) Scientific Journal.

All the amendments into the manuscript must be approved by the author (or in case of co-authors – with the person responsible for official correspondence). The author/the author responsible for correspondence is obliged to respond within two calendar days since the receipt of the amended text. Should no such response be received within the settled period, the text of the article shall read as accepted.

The editors do not guarantee urgent publication of the materials accepted for publication. The order of publishing is established in accordance with the publication plan of the journal and may be dependent on the thematic scope of a particular issue; the editors, however, retains the right of first-priority publication of the article that received the highest scores by the reviewers.

After the issue is out of print, the editorial board will make sure the author’s copies are mailed to the address stated by the authors (co-authors), as well as that the legal deposit copy is mailed to the respective organizations.

Publication and mailing are free of charge; no author’s fees are paid.

The author has the right to call the article off, without stating the reason. This can be done sending a message through the personal account on the journal’s website (or prior December 31, 2023 – by e-mail) containing the following information:

- surname, name(s) of the author (authors);

- title of the article;

- free form notice stating that from the date of this communication, the manuscript is considered withdrawn.